Start with the work, not a guess.
Plumbing decisions can change when the source is hidden, access is difficult, parts are unavailable, a system is not compatible, or city requirements apply. A useful conversation separates what is known from what still needs to be checked.
Ask for the same details from every option you are comparing: the affected system, confirmed condition, access or opening work, parts or equipment, testing, cleanup, restoration, permit responsibility, exclusions, and the next step if the condition is different than expected.